Most of my favourite homemade costumes start in a closet, not a craft store. A plain dress, a pair of jeans or a black turtleneck does the heavy lifting, and felt, cardboard and a few stitches supply the character. Below are thirty-five looks for women, from Rosie the Riveter to a jellyfish under an umbrella, and for each one I've noted the base garment, the hair and makeup, the one prop worth making and the shoes you can actually stand in. I build almost everything here to come apart afterwards, so the dress goes back in the wardrobe on November 1st.
Attaching Felt and Trim Without Ruining the Dress
Nearly every costume below adds felt shapes, fringe, pom-poms or patches to clothes you want to wear again. How you attach them decides whether the dress survives. I sort the options by how long the piece needs to last and how much it gets handled.
- Safety pins are fine for patches and badges on sturdy fabrics like denim and flannel. Pin from the inside so the head of the pin hides behind the patch.
- Double-sided fabric tape holds light felt on cotton and knits for an evening. It lets go on fuzzy or stretchy fabric and once it warms up against skin, so press it hard and give it a minute before you dress.
- Long running stitches by hand are my default for anything that moves, such as fringe, pom-poms and collars. They take minutes, hold through hugs and pull out with one snip.
- Hot glue belongs on headbands, cardboard and foam, not on clothes. It peels off polyester, goes stiff and brittle in cold air, and leaves a mark on fabric that won't wash out.
Before attaching anything, put the outfit on and mark the positions with chalk or pins while you stand in front of a mirror. Felt seeds, spots and stars always sit differently on a body than on a dress laid flat on the table.
1. Rosie The Riveter Costume
Rosie is the costume I suggest when someone has one evening and no sewing machine. High-waisted jeans and a chambray or denim shirt, sleeves rolled above the elbow and tucked in tight, give you her workwear outline. The red bandana with white dots is what people read first, so fold it into a long band and knot it on top of your head over a loose updo; pin it to the hair at both temples or it creeps back by the second hour. Red lipstick, groomed brows and a little wing of liner finish her face. A cardboard "We Can Do It" sign is optional, and brown lace-up boots keep the workwear honest.
2. Wednesday Addams Costume
For Wednesday, the white collar matters more than the dress. If your black dress has none, wear a white button-down underneath and pull the collar and cuffs out over the top; I press the collar points flat so they sit crisp instead of curling. Opaque black tights, then loafers, Mary Janes or low boots. Part the hair dead centre and plait two tight braids, or use a black wig if your hair is short. Keep the face matte and pale with a muted berry lip, and carry a small old book or a black paper flower.
3. Holly Golightly Costume
Holly Golightly is mostly accessories on a black sheath or a modest black midi. Long black gloves, several strands of faux pearls and big sunglasses do the work, and a high bun with a small rhinestone comb pushed in at the front gives the height her evening look needs. I tell people to try the gloves on with the dress before the night; cheap satin gloves are often short and wrinkle at the wrist. Defined lashes, arched brows, pink blush and a pale rose lip. Skip the original smoking holder and carry a black clutch or a paper coffee cup instead, with kitten heels, flats or pointed pumps.
4. Pink Fashion Doll Costume
The fashion doll is easy to buy the clothes for and harder to make look intentional. Go head to toe in one strong pink: a dress, a jumpsuit or a matching top and skirt, with a narrow belt, bright costume jewellery and a small structured bag. A smooth ponytail suits most hair, or wear a wig in whatever doll colour you like. The cardboard toy-box frame is the part people photograph, so paint it a shade deeper than your clothes so you don't disappear into it, and cut it narrow enough to fit through a doorway. White sneakers or pink flats will carry you all night.
5. Classic Scarecrow Costume
A scarecrow forgives everything, which is why I like it for outdoor parties. Denim overalls over a plaid shirt, with felt or scrap patches held on by safety pins or fabric tape so nothing is permanent. Real straw sheds everywhere, so I tie short bundles of raffia or yellow yarn at the cuffs instead. Loose braids or low pigtails under a floppy hat, a stitched smile drawn in eyeliner and orange blush across the nose and cheeks. A fabric sunflower or a small stuffed crow is a friendlier prop than anything scary. Wear leggings under the overalls on a cold night and pick boots you can walk across grass in.
6. Friendly Witch Costume
A witch can be built on almost any long black base: a maxi dress, a skirt and blouse, or wide-leg jumpsuit. The hat makes or breaks it. Poster board rolled into a cone and taped inside will stand up, but it crushes in a car, so I make it last and carry it in. A purple scarf or a velvet-look cape adds colour without tipping into scary. Loose waves or a coloured wig, plum eyeshadow and a berry lip. The broom is a wooden dowel with brown paper bundled and tied at one end; sand the dowel tip so it doesn't snag. Striped tights and buckled ankle boots, and you can add or drop layers to match the weather.
7. Black Cat Costume
The black cat is the costume I'd pick for anyone handing out treats on a doorstep, because nothing sticks out. Black leggings or trousers with a fitted long-sleeve top or a jumpsuit. Glue black felt ears with pink centres onto a plain headband; felt sold on a stiff backing holds its point far better than soft craft felt, which flops after an hour. For the tail, stuff a leg of old black tights and stitch or safety-pin it firmly inside the waistband, because a clipped-on tail falls off the first time you sit. A small drawn nose, whiskers, a cat-eye flick and a ribbon collar with a light bell. Black sneakers or flats.
8. Woodland Deer Costume
The deer depends on texture more than colour. A tan sweater dress, a brown jumpsuit or a brown top with leggings, plus a strip of cream faux fur around the neckline. Cut the ears from brown and pink felt and glue them to a headband next to small cardboard antlers wrapped in kraft paper; keep the antlers short, because tall ones tip the headband backwards. Soft waves or two little space buns under the headpiece. Brown shadow, a darkened nose tip and white dots along the cheekbones, which I set with a dusting of powder so they don't smudge. Brown boots or neutral flats.
9. Colorful Butterfly Costume
Wings are the whole butterfly, so I spend my time there. Black clothing underneath, a dress or a top and leggings, with bright tights or a coloured belt. Cut two matching wings from cardboard or flexible craft foam, using the first as a template for the second, then cover them in painted paper, fabric scraps or tissue patterns. Elastic shoulder straps should be wide; thin elastic digs in within an hour. Pipe-cleaner antennae on a headband, hair up so it doesn't hide the wings, and bright eye makeup matched to the wing colours. Before you leave, walk through your own front door wearing them.
10. Red Ladybug Costume
A ladybug needs almost no sewing. A red dress, sweater or long-sleeve top over black leggings or opaque tights, with black felt circles held on by removable fabric tape. The wings are two rounded pieces of red poster board with black spots, joined at the top and strapped on with black ribbon. I keep them no wider than my shoulders, because poster board bends the first time someone brushes past you in a crowd. Pipe-cleaner antennae on a headband, a sleek ponytail or two buns, rosy blush and a red lip. Black flats or low boots.
11. Floating Jellyfish Costume
The jellyfish is mostly an umbrella, and that's why it looks so much harder than it is. A clear umbrella carries the effect, with ribbon, mesh, crepe paper and curling gift ribbon tied around the ribs and hanging from the edge. Wear a pale blue, white, lavender or iridescent dress over leggings underneath. Cut every streamer to end above your knees; anything longer wraps round your legs or someone else's. If you add battery lights, use ones that stay cool and switch off easily. Soft waves with pearl clips, shimmery blue or lilac eyes, and silver sneakers or flats.
12. Potted Cactus Costume
The cactus is funny and very comfortable, provided you keep the spines soft. A green dress or green separates, with short spines of white yarn, pipe cleaner or felt attached with fabric-safe tape. Never use anything stiff or sharp; you'll be hugged and squeezed past all night. Tissue-paper flowers pinned at one shoulder or on a green headband, with hair up in a high bun so they show. For the pot, I wrap a brown fabric panel around the hips rather than wearing a cardboard ring, because fabric lets you sit. Green shadow, peach blush, green tights and matching flats.
13. Sunflower Costume
With the sunflower, the petal crown is what reads. Wear a brown dress, brown overalls, or a green top with a brown skirt. Cut big petals from yellow felt or cardstock and glue them around a sturdy, wide headband; a thin one twists under the weight. Two green felt leaves at the sides help. Felt petals droop less than you'd think and are much kinder on your neck than a cardboard face frame, which also blocks your side view. Low bun or braids behind the crown, golden shadow and warm blush. A small watering can or a bunch of faux sunflowers, with green tights and brown boots.
14. Strawberry Costume
A plain red dress turns into a strawberry with felt seeds and a leafy headpiece. Cut small teardrops of white or pale yellow felt and space them evenly; I tape one row first, then step back and check the spacing in a mirror before doing the rest, because uneven seeds look like spots. Separates work too: a red sweater with a red skirt or trousers. Green felt leaves on a headband, and a green cardigan for warmth that still suits the theme. Pink cheeks, a red tinted balm and a little green basket. Red flats or green sneakers.
15. Gumball Machine Costume
A gumball machine is all pom-poms, and how you fix them decides how long it lasts. A white or pale grey top over a red skirt, trousers or overalls, with multicoloured craft pom-poms across the front only. Glue holds them for photos, but a few hand stitches through each one survive hugs and a coat going on and off. Leave the back bare so you can sit. A silver and black felt coin slot pinned at the waist is the detail people point at. High ponytail with bright clips, rosy blush, a small silver cardboard box, and red sneakers or white flats.
16. Colorful Crayon Costume
The crayon works in any colour you already own top to bottom: a matching dress and tights, or a same-colour shirt, trousers and cardigan. A black paper band and a wavy strip around the waist and chest copy the wrapper without any logo. The pointed hat is poster board in the same shade with an elastic under the chin; measure the cone to your head first, because too wide and it sits on your ears. Hair smooth or tucked under the hat, eyeshadow and lipstick lightly matched, and an oversized cardboard colouring sheet if you want a prop.
17. Artist Paint Palette Costume
The paint palette lives or dies on foam board. Cut a big oval with a thumb hole, paint bright circles on it, and strap it across your body with wide ribbon. Foam board is light and stiff, but it dents when it gets knocked, so I seal the painted side with a coat of clear varnish. Make sure your arms swing freely before you commit to the strap position. A black turtleneck with trousers, leggings or a plain dress underneath, a beret with a tiny felt splatter, and a stroke or two of face paint near one cheek. A big brush from a cardboard tube with yarn bristles, and black loafers or sneakers.
18. Weather Forecast Costume
The weather costume is a fun one to make with a friend because the pieces are small and quick. Start with something blue: a dress, a sweatshirt dress or a blue top and trousers. Soft white felt clouds, yellow paper suns and blue ribbon raindrops go across different areas, and a craft-foam rainbow sits near one shoulder. Paper suns crumple in a bag, so I cut them from felt when I can. A cloud-shaped hair clip, pale blue shadow, and a small sign split into sunny, cloudy and rainy. Silver rain boots are a nice joke, but white sneakers are kinder on a long day. Stitch or tape everything flat so it doesn't flap.
19. Sparkly Disco Ball Costume
A disco ball doesn't need a structure, only a lot of small squares. Begin with a silver dress, a metallic top and skirt, or a grey jumpsuit, and attach squares of holographic paper or light silver wrap in straight rows. Rows matter more than you'd guess; a chalk grid drawn first keeps them from drifting. Leave out glass, sharp foil and anything rigid and mirrored, because it cuts fabric and fingers. Leave the sides plainer so you can bend and dance. Big curls or a voluminous blowout, silver lids and glossy lips, hoop earrings, and silver sneakers or low platforms.
20. Pop Art Comic Costume
Pop art is a makeup costume more than a sewing one, and it's honest work with eyeliner. A bright dress, a polka-dot blouse with a solid skirt, or a primary-colour jumpsuit sets the palette. Draw bold lines around the brows and lips with a skin-safe black liner, add white dots over one cheek, and finish with a red lip and blue shadow. Liquid liner lasts far longer than pencil here; pencil smears as soon as your face warms up. A paper speech bubble with a short, friendly word on a headband or stick, plus red flats or yellow sneakers.
21. Silent Film Star Costume
The silent film star has to be strictly black, white and grey, and colour sneaks in through bags and shoes. A black midi or a white blouse with a black skirt, grey tights and faux pearls. I cover a small modern purse in black fabric with a few stitches so its brand colour doesn't break the look. Finger waves, a low bun or curls pinned close to the head, with grey contour, black liner and a muted berry lip that reads dark in photos. A handmade title card with a short line is the prop people pick up. Black Mary Janes or low pumps you can stand in for hours.
22. 1920s Flapper Costume
A flapper is a plain shift dress plus fringe. Black, navy or a jewel tone, then rows of fringe trim attached with long running stitches or fabric tape so you can take it off later. Start the bottom row first and work up, overlapping each row by a finger width, so the dress swings when you walk. Keep the lowest fringe well above the floor. Long faux pearls, a narrow headband with a brooch, and waves or a pinned faux bob. Smoky eyes and a deep red lip, a small beaded-look pouch, black tights for warmth, and T-straps or low block heels for dancing.
23. 1950s Sock Hop Costume
The sock hop costume is a circle skirt and a tucked-in top, and the skirt does most of the work. Wear a white blouse or fitted knit with a knee-length circle skirt, plus a felt poodle or music note near the hem on fabric tape. A circle skirt is one of the friendliest first sewing projects if you don't own one; it's mostly one long hem. A narrow neck scarf, a cardigan over the shoulders, and a high ribbon ponytail or curled bangs. A cardboard record with your own made-up label, white ankle socks and saddle shoes or clean sneakers. A petticoat adds volume but is optional.
24. 1960s Mod Costume
Mod is about clean shapes, so keep the base simple: a short or knee-length shift in black and white, bright orange, blue or blocks of colour. On a plain dress, felt circles and stripes on fabric tape give the graphic effect without cutting into anything. Tights should be opaque. Big round earrings, a structured mini bag and a smooth bob or flipped ends. Pale shadow and bold upper lashes, with a few drawn lower lashes and a light pink lip. Cardboard sunglasses are fun for photos, but bring your real glasses if you need them. White ankle boots or low block heels.
25. 1970s Disco Costume
Flares and shine make the disco look. Pair flared trousers with a metallic blouse, a sequined thrift find or a wrap shirt, then add a wide belt, big hoops and tinted glasses. If your trousers are straight, open the outer side seam from the knee down and stitch in a triangle of fabric; it's a half-hour job per leg and comes out cleanly afterwards. Bouncy curls or a high ponytail, gold or blue shadow and glossy lips. A cardboard record or star-shaped clutch. If you plan to dance, choose stable shoes over tall platforms.
26. 1980s Workout Costume
The 1980s workout look is the quickest in this list to put together. Leggings with an oversized sweatshirt, a long T-shirt, or a leotard over a fitted top, then leg warmers. I cut those from the sleeves of an old sweater and turn the raw edge under; knit cut edges curl rather than fray, so you can often skip the hem altogether. Clashing colours on purpose, a wide belt, wristbands and a fabric headband. A high side ponytail with a big scrunchie, blue or purple shadow and pink blush. A towel or empty bottle as the prop, and high-top sneakers.
27. 1990s Grunge Costume
Grunge is built from clothes most people already have. A plain fitted tee under an open flannel, with ripped-look jeans, a denim skirt and dark tights, or loose black trousers. Tie a second plaid shirt round the waist for texture. If you want worn edges without wrecking good jeans, rub the hems and pocket corners with sandpaper rather than cutting holes. A messy bun or loose waves, smudged brown liner, matte skin and a berry lip. A cardboard cassette as a prop, and combat-style boots or canvas sneakers. Roomy layers look more right than tight ones.
28. Classic Pirate Costume
A pirate is layering, so pull from the closet before you buy anything. A white peasant blouse or striped shirt with black trousers, a midi skirt or leggings under a tied overskirt. A wide fabric sash, costume jewellery and a vest made by cutting the sleeves off a thrifted top. Wrap a red scarf round your head and leave the hair loose or braided. Bronze shadow and smudged liner. I'd carry a rolled paper map rather than a toy sword, which many parties and schools won't allow anyway. Brown or black boots, and keep the jewellery light so the outfit doesn't drag.
29. Classic Cowgirl Costume
Denim and plaid make an easy cowgirl that suits most settings. Tuck a plaid shirt into jeans, a denim skirt with tights or wide trousers, then add a brown belt and a cowboy-style hat. A fringed vest is one T-shirt cut open down the front with the hem snipped into strips, then stretched so the strips curl. Tie the bandana loosely at the neck. Braids or a low ponytail, warm brown eyes and tinted balm. A coil of soft rope as the prop. Western boots are ideal, but ankle boots work, and trim any fringe that reaches your shins.
30. Retro Flight Attendant Costume
The retro flight attendant needs tailoring more than anything else. A fitted dress or a matching skirt suit in navy, red, teal or royal blue, with a white blouse under separates. Tie a small scarf neatly at the neck; I fold it into a narrow band first so it sits like a uniform rather than a cowl. A wing badge from cardstock, and a small felt pillbox hat held on with hair clips. Make every emblem an original design, not a real airline's. A sleek bun or curled bob, red lips, a tray of empty paper cups or a little suitcase, and low heels or loafers.
31. Black And White Mime Costume
A mime is a striped top and a clean face, so the face deserves the time. Pair black-and-white stripes with black trousers, overalls or a skirt and opaque tights, then add suspenders, white gloves and a black beret. Apply the pale base thinly and press powder over it; a thick layer cracks and rubs off on collars. Black liner for the brows and small lines under the eyes, with a red or black lip kept neat. A low bun or a tucked bob under the beret, and an empty black picture frame to pose through. Flats or sneakers.
32. Stage Magician Costume
For the magician, the cape is the one piece I'd sew properly. A black blazer over a white blouse, with fitted trousers, a midi skirt or a jumpsuit, and a felt bow tie in red. A short black cape lined with red fabric turns the outfit, and hemming it to hip or knee length keeps it out from under your shoes. A top hat from a cardboard tube and a circle brim, covered in black paper. A sleek ponytail, winged liner and red lips. Oversized paper cards or a plush rabbit peeking out of the hat, and black loafers or low boots.
33. Garden Fairy Costume
Fairy wings from wire and sheer fabric are lighter than cardboard and move when you do. Wear a flowing dress or a fitted top with a layered tulle skirt over leggings, in green, lavender, pale pink or sky blue. Bend the wire into two small loops, stretch sheer fabric over them, and wrap every cut end in ribbon or tape so nothing scratches. Tulle snags on everything, so I trim the skirt's top layer shortest. Artificial flowers on a headband, loose curls or a braided updo, shimmer and tiny painted flowers at one temple, and ballet flats or sneakers.
34. Glam Vampire Costume
The glam vampire is about a good collar. A black maxi dress, a velvet-look jumpsuit, or a blouse with a long skirt, plus a high-collared black cape lined in deep red. To make the collar stand, I fuse a stiff interfacing into it before sewing; without it, the collar folds flat by the end of the evening. Fasten the cape securely at the shoulders. Polished waves or a dark wig, a pale base, smoky plum eyes and a dark red lip, with no gore needed. A red rose or a goblet-shaped prop, a lace choker, and pointed flats or heeled boots.
35. Queen Of Hearts Costume
Red, black, white and gold make the Queen of Hearts. A red dress, or a red blouse with a black skirt, with playing-card shapes cut from cardstock along the neckline, waist or hem. The standing collar is the hardest part; white felt alone sags, so I glue it to a backing of thin card cut to the same shape and dot it with red hearts. A light gold paper crown fixed to a headband stays straighter than a loose one. Curls or a high updo, a red lip and a small heart under one eye. A fan of big handmade cards, black tights and red flats.
Wings, Hats and Cardboard in a Crowded Room
The pieces that make a homemade costume read from across a room are also the ones that fail first: the butterfly wings, the witch hat, the paint palette, the jellyfish umbrella. I run three checks before anyone wears one out.
The doorway test
Put the costume on and walk through a standard door, then sit in a kitchen chair and get into a car seat. If you have to turn sideways or take something off, trim it now. Wings wider than your shoulders and hats taller than a hand's width above your head both struggle here.
Weight and straps
Anything worn on the shoulders needs straps at least as wide as two fingers, or it bites by the second hour. Anything on a headband should weigh less than the headband can grip; if it slides when you nod, add a comb sewn to the underside or pin it to your hair with bobby pins crossed in an X.
Rain and cold
Cardboard and poster board soften quickly in damp air, and hot glue joins let go in the cold. For an outdoor party, I seal painted cardboard with clear varnish, reinforce glued joins with tape on the inside, and pack a spare headband and a few safety pins in my bag.
The Closet Pieces That Carry Most of These
Look back through this list and the same few garments keep doing the work: a black dress, a pair of jeans, a plaid shirt, a solid-colour top and opaque tights. Check those first, then fill gaps from a thrift shop with felt, cardboard and ribbon. Give each costume one finished detail, such as the collar, the wings or the hat, and keep everything else simple and comfortable for several hours on your feet. If I had to make one tonight with nothing in the house, I'd make the black cat or Rosie, and save the jellyfish for when I have a free afternoon.
Related posts:
