Give me a cardboard box, a bag of felt and an old sheet, and I can get most of a family dressed for Halloween. The costumes here are built from clothes you already own, recycled packaging and cheap craft supplies, and many need no sewing at all. I've mixed solo looks with couples, a group idea and a whole-family theme, and for each one I've noted the base clothes, the headpiece, the makeup, the prop and the shoes. The ones I trust most are the ones you can walk, sit and trick-or-treat in, so I've flagged where a box or a pair of wings needs trimming before the night.
Cutting a Box Costume So It Sits on the Shoulders
Several looks below, like the robot, the popcorn box, the paper doll and the laundry basket, hang a rigid shape on the body. When they go wrong, it's usually because the weight sits on the hips or the arm holes are in the wrong place. This is the order I build them in.
- Measure the wearer across the shoulders and from shoulder to just above the knee. The box or panel should be no wider than the shoulders plus a hand on each side, and no longer than that knee measurement.
- Mark the head and arm openings with the wearer standing in front of you holding the box, not with the box on the table. Arm holes are almost always lower and further forward than people expect.
- Cut with a sharp craft knife on a board, starting small. Tape over every cut edge with masking or duct tape so it doesn't scratch the neck or the inside of the arm.
- Carry the weight on the shoulders with wide ribbon, webbing or cotton tape, crossing behind the back if the box tips forward.
- Paint or cover it last. Wet paint softens corrugated cardboard, so use thin coats and let each one dry, or wrap it in paper instead.
Before decorating, have the wearer sit in a chair and climb into the car with the bare box on. If either is a struggle, trim now while it's only cardboard.
1. Homemade Scarecrow Costume
Start a scarecrow with clothes that already look lived in. A plaid flannel under denim overalls or loose jeans, with fabric patches sewn on using big, deliberately clumsy stitches in contrasting thread; the bad stitching is the point. Stuff raffia or yellow paper strips into the cuffs and pockets. I skip real straw entirely, especially near small children, because it scratches and sheds on every car seat and sofa. Braids or a low ponytail under a straw hat with felt leaves, a stitched smile in brown liner, and orange circles on the cheeks. A fabric crow or a small pumpkin bucket, thick socks and brown boots.
2. Homemade Classic Ghost Costume
Want a ghost that looks finished rather than like laundry? Put the sheet over a white sweatshirt and leggings for warmth, and wear a white beanie underneath, because the beanie is what stops the sheet sliding and moving your eyeholes. Mark the eye positions with a pencil while the sheet is on, then cut small and widen if needed. Trim the hem so it clears your shoes, and cut the edge into soft, uneven curves. Pale makeup around the eyes, a white bucket or a painted oatmeal-tin lantern, and white sneakers. Sheer fabric strips on the arms give a floating effect; keep them short.
3. Homemade Friendly Witch Costume
My friendly witch starts with black separates: a long-sleeve top, a flowing midi skirt, striped tights and buckled ankle boots. The hat is poster board rolled into a cone, then covered in black felt, which hides the seam and stops the poster board shine. A purple ribbon band or paper stars finish it. Loose waves, a side braid or a messy bun underneath. Purple shadow, rosy blush and a berry lip read as cheerful rather than frightening. A thrifted shawl or tulle cape adds movement, and a broom from a painted dowel and raffia, or a stuffed black cat, is the prop. Hem the skirt above the ankle for stairs.
4. Homemade Black Cat Costume
The black cat is nearly all closet. A fitted black sweater or sweatshirt with black trousers, leggings or a skirt and tights. Cut two felt triangles and glue them to a plain headband, then glue a second, slightly smaller triangle behind each so they stand up instead of folding. The tail is stuffed black fabric, pinned with a safety pin on the inside of the waistband where it can't pull through. Whiskers and a nose in washable liner, a little silver on the lids, and flats or sneakers. A ball of yarn made by wrapping a foam ball is a cute prop for kids.
5. Homemade Mime Costume
A mime takes very little crafting and a bit of performing. A black-and-white striped shirt, cropped black trousers and suspenders, then white gloves, a red neck scarf and a black beret. Hair sleek under the hat or in a low bun. I apply the white face makeup in thin layers with a damp sponge and set it with powder; one heavy coat cracks around the mouth within an hour. Black liner for the brows and small lines under the eyes, with a red lip. Loafers or flats with white socks, an empty frame to pose in, and a few silent poses practised before you go.
6. Homemade Artist Costume
The artist costume is a good use for old overalls. A striped tee underneath, then paint splashes on the overalls, either cut from felt and pinned on or dabbed with washable fabric paint you've tested on an inside seam first. Wet-looking paint is a bad idea at a party; it ends up on furniture. A red neck scarf and a soft black beret, hair in a loose braid or tousled. A few colourful streaks on one cheek and a fresh face otherwise. A cardboard palette with painted circles, a handful of clean brushes and canvas sneakers.
7. Homemade Tourist Costume
The tourist is the costume I suggest at four o'clock on the day of the party. A loud floral shirt, khaki shorts or relaxed trousers, crew socks pulled high and comfortable sneakers. A jacket tied round the waist if it's cool, then a sun hat, sunglasses and a camera made from a small box painted black with a bottle-cap lens. A stripe of white makeup on the nose for the sunscreen joke. A folded map, a homemade visitor badge and a crossbody pouch. Skip big bags; they bump everyone in a crowded room.
8. Homemade Detective Costume
The detective comes together from neutral layers: a white shirt, dark trousers, a sweater vest and a belted tan trench, with a plaid cap or a fedora. The coat is the part that sells it, so if yours is heavy, a lighter thrifted mac is kinder for a warm room. Hair tidy under the hat and natural makeup with defined brows. A magnifying glass from a cardboard ring and clear plastic from food packaging, a small notebook of made-up clues, and a paper badge in a wallet. Brown loafers or lace-up boots.
9. Homemade Gardener Costume
The gardener works for any age and any weather. Denim overalls over a green or floral shirt, with a canvas apron whose pockets hold faux flowers, seed packets and clean gloves. A floppy sun hat over braids or pigtails, rosy cheeks and a tiny painted ladybug at one temple. Carry a light watering can or a basket of silk vegetables, never real tools. I pin felt leaves to the overalls with the pins hidden behind the leaf, so they don't scratch a child who leans in for a hug. Green rain boots or brown work boots.
10. Homemade Chef Costume
A chef needs a hat that stays up, and that's the only tricky part. Start with a white shirt, black trousers and a white apron. For the hat, a band of white poster board sized to the head, with white tissue paper gathered and taped inside to puff over the top; I fit the band first and add the tissue last, so it doesn't drop over the eyes. Hair tied back underneath. A curled liner moustache if you want the laugh. A mixing bowl and wooden spoon or a silver cardboard tray, and nonslip shoes. Leave real knives and breakable dishes at home.
11. Homemade Rain Cloud Costume
Grey clothes and polyester stuffing make the rain cloud. Wear a grey sweatshirt with joggers, leggings or trousers. Hand-stitch or glue fluffs of stuffing over a wide-brimmed hat or a light cardboard headpiece; less stuffing than you think, because it gets heavy and hot. Short blue ribbons and felt raindrops hang from the brim, ending above the shoulders. Hair in a low ponytail, silver shadow and a sparkly raindrop on one cheek. A closed blue umbrella dotted with felt drops is a good prop where the venue allows it. Wear the headpiece around the house for ten minutes first.
12. Homemade Jellyfish Costume
The jellyfish is about movement, so pick streamers that catch the light. A white, lavender, pink or pale blue base, like a sweatshirt dress with leggings, and a clear umbrella with ribbon, rickrack and iridescent cellophane tied to the ribs. I cut every streamer to end at mid-thigh; any lower and they wrap round your legs when you turn. A sleek ponytail or bun under the umbrella, pearly shadow and small face gems. Metallic sneakers or flat rain boots. Close the umbrella indoors when it gets crowded, and use only lights that are enclosed and stay cool.
13. Homemade Bubble Bath Costume
The bubble bath is all white on white with clusters of bubbles. A white sweatshirt with white leggings, trousers or a skirt and tights. Balloons look the part, but they pop and squeak, so I use them only for photos and switch to white foam craft balls for a long evening. Leave the face and arms clear. A shower cap over tucked hair, pink cheeks and a little pearly highlighter. A rubber duck and a cardboard bath brush, or a few light toy ducks among the bubbles. Underinflate any balloons you use and attach everything with fabric-safe methods.
14. Homemade Popcorn Box Costume
The popcorn box is two panels of poster board, front and back. Paint vertical red stripes using painter's tape as a guide; freehand stripes always lean. Join the panels with wide ribbon at the shoulders and sides, and end them above the knees so you can walk. Crumpled white tissue with dabs of yellow paint makes the popcorn, glued round the neckline and on a headband. A white shirt with red trousers or a skirt underneath, red lips and gold shadow, plus a ticket sign. Round every corner with scissors and tape the shoulder joins on both sides.
15. Homemade Gumball Machine Costume
The gumball machine looks detailed with very little work. A red skirt or trousers with a fitted white or grey top, and felt circles or soft pom-poms across the front. A wide grey belt carries a cardboard coin slot, and a red beanie with one big felt circle stands in for the top of the machine. Decorate only the front and upper sides, or you'll be sitting on pom-poms all night and the jacket won't go on. Hair behind the shoulders, pink blush and dots of coloured liner. Red flats or sneakers and a round silver candy bucket.
16. Homemade Crayon Costume
A crayon works for a child or an adult in any colour they own head to toe: a solid T-shirt or sweatshirt with matching trousers or a skirt and tights. Cut black felt into wavy bands for the cuffs, waist and lower legs, and stitch them on loosely; felt stuck to a sweatshirt with glue peels off at the first wash or the first hug. A pointed poster-board hat with elastic under the chin. Matching clips or a little hair chalk, a wash of matching shadow, and a cardboard colour label on the chest. Shoes in the same colour, or plain black.
17. Homemade Pencil Costume
The pencil pairs nicely with the crayon if two kids want to match without being the same thing. Yellow top and trousers, leggings or a straight skirt, with a silver felt band at the waist and a removable pink fabric panel below it for the eraser. The hat is a cone of tan poster board with a black paper tip; tuck hair into a low bun so the cone sits straight. Golden shadow and a sharp black flick. Carry a small notebook with a big, funny message written on the cover in washable marker, and yellow sneakers or black lace-ups.
18. Homemade Cactus Costume
For a cactus, felt and yarn give you the look without anything prickly. A green sweatshirt with matching joggers or trousers, with short white yarn pieces stitched in small groups of three to suggest spines. Pink and yellow felt flowers on one shoulder and on a green headband. Hair up so the flowers show, green liner and a small painted flower on one cheekbone. Green sneakers or brown boots, and a flowerpot candy bucket from painted cardboard. Keep the yarn short; long pieces snag on chair backs and look like loose threads.
19. Homemade Sunflower Costume
This sunflower moves the petals to a collar if a headpiece won't stay on. Green long-sleeve top and green trousers, leggings or a flowing skirt. Glue big yellow felt petals around a fabric-covered headband, or sew them to a soft circular collar, which is my choice for children who pull at anything on their heads. Felt leaves on the sleeves and waist where they won't get in the way. Hair low behind the petals, golden shadow and a tiny painted leaf. A small watering can or a basket of faux sunflowers, and brown boots or green sneakers. Keep stiff cardboard away from the face.
20. Homemade Ladybug Costume
For the ladybug, the straps matter more than the wings. A red sweatshirt or dress with black leggings, tights or trousers, and evenly spaced felt spots on removable fabric tape. Two rounded wings of red poster board with black spots, held on by soft backpack-style straps; I sew those from wide elastic so they don't slide off a narrow child's shoulders. A black headband with short chenille antennae, pigtails or buns, a red lip and little dots at the eye corners. Black sneakers or flats, and wings narrower than the shoulders for classrooms and doorways.
21. Homemade Butterfly Costume
Fabric wings are the butterfly I'd make for someone who wants to dance. Black top with black leggings, trousers or a simple dress and tights, then one large wing shape cut from light fabric, decorated with matching felt patterns on each side. Soft elastic loops at the wrists and shoulders mean the wings open when the arms lift. Hem or pink the edges so they don't fray. A headband with curled antennae, a smooth bun, colourful shadow matched to the wings and a few face gems. Flats or dance shoes, and keep the fabric well above the ankles.
22. Homemade Cardboard Robot Costume
A robot is the best second life for a delivery box. Wear a grey sweatshirt and sweatpants under a light box with holes cut for the head and arms. Cut those holes a little smaller than you need, try it on, then widen; you can't put cardboard back. Silver paper on the outside, bottle-cap buttons, painted dials and coloured screens. A smaller open-bottom box or a silver beanie for the head, metallic face paint on the cheeks and black lines at the brows. Tape over every cut edge, pull out all staples, and keep the box above the knees.
23. Homemade Green Alien Costume
Neon green carries an alien from across a room. A green sweatshirt dress with leggings or a matching set, a silver belt, metallic cuffs and a headband with two pom-pom antennae. Two high buns or a silver hood. Blend pale green face paint lightly across the cheeks and temples rather than the whole face; full coverage takes ages to remove and rubs off on a collar. Silver shadow and tiny stars. A cardboard flying-saucer purse, silver flats or white boots. No full-face masks, which cut down what you can see. Reflective tape works on the arms if it doesn't stiffen the sleeve.
24. Homemade Astronaut Costume
An astronaut needs white coveralls, a painter's suit or a white sweatshirt with cargo trousers. Silver duct-tape bands at the cuffs and knees look right, but duct tape glue leaves a residue, so I stick it to strips of white fabric first and pin the strips on. Original mission patches, a cardboard chest panel on fabric-safe fasteners, and hair in a low bun or under a white cap. Silver shadow and star details. White sneakers or puffy winter boots. A backpack of two painted bottles on cardboard looks great outside, but leave it off indoors.
25. Homemade Pirate Costume
My pirate comes almost entirely from thrift-store layers. A loose white shirt, cropped black trousers or a striped midi skirt, a wide red sash, a dark vest, striped socks and brown boots. Tie a printed scarf over waves or braids. Rub a little washable brown chalk on the hems and elbows for a sea-worn look; it brushes off afterwards. Smudged brown shadow and rosy cheeks. A paper treasure map, toy compass or cardboard spyglass instead of a weapon, plus gold clip-on earrings and beads. Pin the sash so it doesn't slip loose while you walk.
26. Homemade Cowgirl Costume
The cowgirl is everyday denim and plaid. A plaid shirt with jeans or a denim skirt and tights, a brown belt, a fringed vest, a bandana and a wide-brim hat. Two braids or a low ponytail under the hat, warm makeup and a few drawn freckles. Brown ankle or western boots. A hobby horse, a coil of soft rope or a silver cardboard horseshoe. Felt stars on the vest avoid copying a real badge. Outdoors, I stitch a loop of thin elastic inside the hat so it sits under the hair at the back; a gust otherwise takes it off.
27. Homemade Mad Scientist Costume
The mad scientist is a white coat over colour. An oversized white shirt or thrifted lab coat over a bright top and dark trousers, mismatched gloves, a loud bow tie and pens in the pocket. Tease the hair up or use temporary white hair spray, which I'd test on a strand first because it can look chalky on dark hair. Grey smudges on the cheeks, bold brows and green liner. Plastic test tubes with coloured water, sealed tight, a clipboard of silly formulas or a foam invention. Crooked buttons and patches add character. Boots or sneakers.
28. Homemade Tooth Fairy Costume
A tooth fairy is soft pastels and a clear prop. A pale blue, lavender or white dress over leggings, or a sparkly top with a tulle skirt. The wings are sheer fabric stretched over rounded cardboard frames, then strapped on like a backpack; cardboard frames bend if they're thin, so I glue two layers together. A crown or star headband over curls or a bun, pearly shadow and a touch of glitter, which spreads everywhere, so go easy. Silver flats or white sneakers. A soft fabric tooth pouch and a star wand from a dowel and felt.
29. Homemade Storybook Nanny Costume
The storybook nanny is neat, buttoned and a little old-fashioned. A white blouse fastened to the collar, a dark midi skirt and a fitted black or navy jacket, with opaque tights, lace-up ankle boots and a small hat with faux daisies. A smooth low bun under the hat, rosy blush and a red lip. A closed umbrella, a fabric carpetbag or a giant cardboard spoon is the prop people expect. White gloves and a red bow tie finish it. Keep the skirt at mid-calf; full length catches on stairs. It suits adults, teachers and older children.
30. Homemade Paper Doll Costume
The paper doll is clever because it's flat. Wear a plain sleeveless dress or a solid top and skirt, then cut oversized outfit shapes, bows and buttons from light poster board and strap them over the clothes. White rectangular tabs at the shoulders, waist and shoe covers are the detail that makes it read as a paper doll rather than a sandwich board. A smooth bob or curls with a big flat bow, round blush and neat liner. I keep each board piece narrower than the body behind it and round every corner. Simple flats under the shoe panels.
31. Homemade Wind-Up Toy Costume
The wind-up toy rests on one big prop: the key. A bright dress with puffed sleeves, or a fitted vest with cropped trousers and a bow tie, plus striped tights or tall socks and polished flats. Cut the key from two layers of cardboard glued together, paint it gold or silver and fasten it to the back with elastic straps that cross over the chest. Make it narrower than your shoulders and easy to unhook for the car. Tight curls or two buns, round blush and a small heart lip, with white gloves. Stiff little movements do the rest.
32. Homemade Bee And Beekeeper Couple Costume
The bee and the beekeeper make sense the moment the two of you walk in together. The bee wears a black-and-yellow striped top, black trousers or a tulle skirt with tights, short wings, an antenna headband and black shoes, with yellow eye makeup and two small buns. The beekeeper wears beige coveralls or khakis with a light shirt, boots, gloves and a wide-brim hat with white mesh around the brim. I gather the mesh so it hangs at the back and sides, leaving the face open. A cardboard honeycomb and a bucket to share, and felt bees on the beekeeper's sleeves.
33. Homemade Campfire And Marshmallows Group Costume
The campfire and marshmallows is the group costume I'd suggest for three or four friends, because only one person has real work to do. The campfire wears brown with felt logs and layered red, orange and yellow fabric flames, a flame headband, warm eye makeup and brown boots. Everyone else is a marshmallow in a white sweatshirt, white trousers, a white beanie and white sneakers, with a brown cardboard band round the waist for the roasting stick, kept tight to the body. Matching rosy cheeks help the group read as one. Use soft fabric throughout so you can all sit together.
34. Homemade Garden Family Costume
A garden family gives each person a different costume that still belongs to the same theme. One adult is the gardener in overalls, gloves, a sun hat, boots and a light watering can. Another is a flower in green clothes with a felt-petal headpiece. A child wears the ladybug, with red clothes, black spots, small wings and antennae. A baby can be a caterpillar in a green footed sleepsuit and a soft antenna hat. Simple makeup with rosy cheeks and small leaf or dot designs, and a basket of faux flowers carried between you. Everything should be soft enough to hug and squash into a stroller.
35. Homemade Laundry Basket Costume
The laundry basket is a good joke built from things in your utility room. A clean T-shirt, patterned pyjama trousers and slippers or sneakers. Cut the base out of a lightweight plastic basket, cover the cut edge with thick tape, since cut plastic is sharp, and hang it at the waist from wide fabric straps over the shoulders. Fill it with clean socks, small towels and light clothes, safety-pinned so they stay put. A messy bun with a lost sock as a headband, tired-looking liner and a rinsed-out detergent bottle or a cardboard one. Keep the basket above the knees.
Trick-or-Treat Checks for the Younger Ones
Plenty of these, like the crayon, pencil, ladybug, ghost and astronaut, end up on children. Kids pull off anything that itches, trip on anything that drags, and get cold faster than adults standing still on a doorstep. These are the checks I run on a child's homemade costume before it leaves the house.
- Can they see? Swap masks for face paint, and widen ghost eyeholes until they can see their own feet when they look down.
- Can they be seen? Dark costumes like the black cat and the witch need a strip of reflective tape on the back and sleeves, or a small light on the bucket.
- Does anything drag? Hems, sheets, capes and streamers should all clear the ankle with the child walking, not just standing.
- Is it warm enough? Build the costume over a thermal layer from the start, so a coat isn't covering the whole idea.
- Will it come off fast? Toilet trips are the real test. Separates beat one-piece builds, and anything strapped on should unhook in seconds.
Face paint deserves its own check. Dab a little on the inside of the child's wrist the day before and look for redness, and take it off at night with oil or a gentle cleanser rather than scrubbing with a wet cloth.
Which One Gets Made This Weekend?
Every costume above starts with familiar clothes, a bit of recycled packaging and a few craft supplies. Pick by who's wearing it and what they'll be doing: a box robot suits a party, a cat or a gardener suits a long walk. Then do a dress rehearsal a few days early. Check that hems clear the shoes, headpieces stay put when you nod, props are light, and nothing blocks the eyes. Change the colours, add layers for the weather, or link a few looks for a couple, group or family. If the wearer forgets they have it on, you've made it well.
Related posts:
